The story of the Pythagorean Theorem is a classic example of how ideas transcend time and geography, often becoming attributed to the wrong person. The theorem, which is named after the Greek philosopher Pythagoras, may well be one of the oldest examples of scientific plagiarism in history. In reality, the mathematical relationship that Pythagoras is credited with had been known to earlier civilizations, such as the Babylonians, centuries before his birth.
Mathematical Achievements of the Mesopotamians
Babylonian mathematics, inherited from the ancient Sumerians and Akkadians, was far more advanced than that of Egypt during the same period. The Babylonians were able to solve quadratic equations, work with geometric progressions, and understand proportions and percentages. Their expertise allowed them to construct architectural marvels like the ziggurats — intricate multi-story structures more complex than the pyramids.
The Sumerians’ contributions to mathematics include the creation of a numerical system based on the base 60, which influenced many later practices, including how we divide time (60 minutes in an hour, 60 seconds in a minute). However, the Babylonians improved upon this by introducing a positional system that allowed for more advanced calculations.
One of the most intriguing discoveries from Babylonian mathematics is the use of the Pythagorean theorem, long before Pythagoras. This is demonstrated by the famous Babylonian clay tablet, dated around 1770 BCE, which reveals the use of the theorem to calculate the diagonal of a square. This discovery occurred more than 1,000 years before Pythagoras was born.
The Babylonian Tablet and the Pythagorean Theorem
The clay tablet known as IM 67118, discovered in Iraq, is an important artifact that showcases Babylonian mathematical sophistication. The tablet outlines the calculation of the diagonal of a square, demonstrating a clear understanding of the relationship that would later be called the Pythagorean theorem. The theorem states that in a right-angled triangle, the square of the hypotenuse (the longest side) is equal to the sum of the squares of the other two sides. The fact that this was known over a millennium before Pythagoras’s time challenges the traditional narrative of the theorem’s origin.
The tablet is a significant reminder of how the Babylonians made remarkable contributions to mathematics and geometry, which later influenced other civilizations, particularly the Greeks. Yet, despite this early evidence, it was Pythagoras who became immortalized in the theorem's name. This leads to the intriguing question: why is Pythagoras credited with the theorem?
The Oldest Example of Scientific Plagiarism
While many attribute the discovery of the Pythagorean theorem to Pythagoras, it seems clear that the Greek philosopher did not originate the idea. Instead, it is likely that Pythagoras encountered the theorem during his travels and studies. Ancient biographies of Pythagoras describe him as an inquisitive and well-traveled man who spent time studying in Egypt and Babylon, where he would have been exposed to the mathematical knowledge of those civilizations.
There are various stories about Pythagoras’s discovery of the theorem, including one where he allegedly discovered it while observing the tiling patterns on his palace floor. However, the lack of concrete primary sources from Pythagoras himself has led historians to speculate that his followers may have attributed the theorem to him as part of a tradition of honoring their teacher. In the absence of written records by Pythagoras himself, much of what we know about him comes from his disciples, who may have exaggerated his contributions.
The Pythagoreans were a religious-philosophical group founded by Pythagoras in southern Italy. Their reverence for their master likely led them to claim various discoveries in his name, and this could explain why the Babylonian discovery of the Pythagorean theorem became associated with Pythagoras, even though it was known centuries before his birth.
The Spread of the Theorem Across Cultures
Interestingly, the Pythagorean theorem was not unique to the Babylonians. The ancient Indian scholar Baudhāyana, who lived around 800 BCE, described a version of the theorem in his Vedic texts, predating Pythagoras by several centuries. Similarly, in China, the theorem was also known. According to ancient Chinese accounts, the legendary Yellow Emperor (Huang Di), who reigned around 2600 BCE, instructed his minister, Li Shou, to compile works on mathematics, which included the concept of the Pythagorean theorem.
These discoveries suggest an interconnectedness between the mathematical knowledge of India, Mesopotamia, and China, highlighting how mathematical ideas were shared and refined across different cultures. The spread of such knowledge across vast geographical distances speaks to the human desire for understanding and sharing ideas, regardless of political or cultural boundaries.
The Pythagorean theorem, as we know it today, is not solely the product of one man's genius. Instead, it is a testament to the collaborative and cumulative nature of human knowledge. The Babylonians, Indians, and Chinese all contributed to the development of this fundamental mathematical relationship. Pythagoras’s role in the theorem’s history seems to be more about popularizing and codifying it rather than inventing it.
In light of the evidence from ancient civilizations, it is fair to question the attribution of the Pythagorean theorem solely to Pythagoras. While Pythagoras may have been instrumental in shaping the theorem into a formalized part of Greek mathematics, the real story of the Pythagorean theorem is one of cross-cultural exchange, with knowledge being passed down and built upon across generations and civilizations.
No comments:
Post a Comment